When comparing the historical pie method versus modern steaming/grilling for lamprey, what does the pie method suggest about historical awareness of the fish's traits?

Answer

Historical cooks were acutely aware of the need to balance the lamprey’s inherent characteristics.

The traditional lamprey pie preparation involves robust elements like a heavy pastry crust and a strongly acidic sauce made from wine or vinegar. This contrasts with simpler modern techniques like steaming and grilling, which rely more on the fish’s inherent profile. The necessity of incorporating such strong balancing agents in the historical method suggests that cooks centuries ago were acutely aware of the strong, potentially overwhelming characteristics of the fish and deliberately employed these additions to achieve palatability, a tactic that simple grilling might fail to replicate effectively.

When comparing the historical pie method versus modern steaming/grilling for lamprey, what does the pie method suggest about historical awareness of the fish's traits?
foodanimaltastelamprey